| Year | Miss Downey | Year | Miss Teen Downey |
| 2009 | Kathia Morales | 2009 | Sandy Fernandez |
| 2008 | Sarah Lopez | 2008 | Carli Ciatti |
| 2007 | Brianna Arceo | 2007 | Ashley Campuzano |
| 2006 | Kimberly Scott | 2006 | Denise Antillon |
| 2005 | Robyn Guggiana | 2005 | Jacquelinne Mejia |
| 2004 | Brittnay Fitzgerald | 2004 | Brianna Arceo |
| 2003 | Stephanie Cuellar | 2003 | Amanda Thoreson |
| 2002 | Lindsay Mitchum | 2002 | Ashley Guzman |
| 2001 | Stephanie Tauson | 2001 | Amanda McGrew |
| 2000 | Kellie Macintosh | 2000 | Heather Rash |
| 1999 | Amy Olds | 1999 | Anika McQuarn |
| 1999 | Michelle Baez | ||
| 1998 | Jaclyn Tesoriero | 1998 | Tiffany Hill |
| Year | Name | Year | Name |
| 1997 | Miss Roberta Camaj | 1975 | Miss Melinda Jansen |
| 1996 | Miss Misty Gray | 1974 | Miss Karren Turner |
| 1995 | Miss Ericka DeRemer | 1973 | Miss Sherry Van Meter |
| 1994 | Miss Elizabeth Balderas | 1972 | Miss Janet Weinreich |
| 1993 | Miss Joleen Mahili | 1971 | Miss Rhonda Weinberg |
| 1992 | Miss Nancy Rivas | 1970 | Miss Ann Sunnum |
| 1991 | Miss Dionne Rogers | 1969 | Miss Leslie McLelian |
| 1990 | Miss Heather Nelson | 1968 | Miss Debbie Derry |
| 1989 | Miss Shelia Forcade | 1967 | Miss Vickie Lee |
| 1988 | Miss Stacy Terrey | 1966 | Miss Sherry Roese |
| 1987 | Miss Monica Garcia | 1965 | Miss Marilyn Granger |
| 1986 | Miss Erika Sziebl | 1964 | Miss Carol Ann Gunnette |
1985 |
Miss Denise Boss | 1963 | Miss Sue Simmons |
| 1984 | Miss Patricia Garcia | 1962 | Miss Lee Ann Paton |
| 1983 | Miss Christina Lopez | 1961 | Miss MaryLou Pouplp |
| 1982 | Miss Susan Pedzimaz | 1960 | Miss Laura Evans |
| 1981 | Miss Deanna Martin | 1959 | Miss Sharon Hillyer |
| 1980 | Miss Roseanne Glinke | 1958 | Miss Marilyn Sue Davis |
| 1979 | Miss Roxanne Wood | 1957 | Miss Jerolyn Stacy |
| 1978 | Miss Lori Lyn Hauser | 1956 | Miss Trudy Cole |
| 1977 | Miss Patricia Meneilly | 1955 | Miss Barbara Boytim |
| 1976 | Miss Robin Demming |
Problems Contact